UAT Studioby Salvion
Compare

UAT in Excel, or in UAT Studio

Most UATs start in a spreadsheet, and for a small one that works. This page says when a spreadsheet is enough, and when a tool saves the test lead the evenings of copying.

In short

Which one fits your UAT

A spreadsheet fitsA small UAT with a few testers in one room, one round, and a test lead who keeps the file up to date.
UAT Studio fitsA go-live with business testers in several teams, issues that go to Jira or Azure DevOps, retests, and a steering committee that wants a go/no-go on facts.
Side by side

Excel and UAT Studio, point by point

ExcelUAT Studio
CostFree, if you have Microsoft 365 or Google WorkspaceFree pilot of 14 days, then from €695 per project or a monthly plan
Business testersEach tester gets a copy or works in a shared fileEach tester sees only their own scripts and signs in with a code by email; no licence
ResultsTyped into the sheet; collected by hand from the copies1Pass, Fail, Blocked or N/A per step, live on the dashboard
EvidenceScreenshots pasted into the file or sent by email1Screenshot, the record link and the error messages with a failed step, from the browser extension
IssuesA tab in the sheet, or copied into Jira by handIssues with screenshots, sent to Jira, Azure DevOps or Salesforce, with the status back
Who changed whatHard to tell who changed a cell, and which copy is the right one2Every result and change has a name and a time; an audit log
Sign-off and go/no-goAn email or a signature on paperSign-off per group, and the go/no-go report as a PDF or slides
The next releaseCopy the file and clear the resultsStart a regression round copies the test cases you choose; Release readiness shows what a Salesforce release touches

Sources read on 4 November 2026; the numbers point to the sources below. Where a page does not say something, we write that, and do not guess. Something out of date? Email [email protected] and we correct it.

Fair to both

What Excel does well, and when UAT Studio fits better

Excel does well
  • Everyone knows it; nothing to buy or learn.
  • Completely free in form: any column you want.
  • Fine for a small UAT with one round.
UAT Studio fits better when
  • More than a handful of testers, in different places.
  • Evidence that must hold up in an audit.
  • Issues that go to developers in Jira, Azure DevOps or Salesforce.
  • A UAT that comes back with every release.

Starting in Excel anyway? Our free UAT template has a test script, an issue log, a dashboard and a sign-off sheet, and imports into UAT Studio as it is when the UAT grows.

See it on your own UAT14 days free, with your own test cases and the connections included.Start pilot
Sources

Where these facts come from

  1. Original Software, 5 reasons to stop using spreadsheets for UAT (19 April 2021). A vendor of test tools. originalsoftware.com
  2. Panko and Ordway, Sarbanes-Oxley: What About All the Spreadsheets? (University of Hawaii). About spreadsheets in general, not only UAT. arxiv.org

Read on 4 November 2026. Excel is a trademark of its owner; UAT Studio is not affiliated with it. Other comparisons: Panaya | Copado Explorer | TestMonitor.